Someone copied your track? Here is what the law really says about music plagiarism
What copyright protects (and does not protect)
“Plagiarism” is the everyday word; the legal term in France is contrefaçon (infringement): reproducing or performing a work, in whole or in part, without the consent of its author or rights holders, outside the exceptions provided by law.
Copyright protects the original form of a work: a melody, lyrics, an arrangement that carries a personal contribution. An idea is not protected as such, and a musical style or genre cannot be owned as such. Very common elements, like a tempo or a common chord progression, are in principle part of the public stock. So two tracks that “sound the same” are not necessarily infringing.
How infringement is assessed
It is assessed case by case, in particular on the basis of similarities in the original elements of the work. Melody, lyrics, harmony, rhythm or structure can be examined, without any single criterion working as an automatic test. A musicological expert opinion may be used when helpful.
What to do if you think you have been plagiarized
- Document before you accuse: links, screenshots, dates, who is exploiting it, files concerned.
- Gather your evidence of creation and prior existence: sessions, dated versions, Musicstart or e-Soleau certificates, SNAC deposit…
- Have the use officially recorded by a commissaire de justice (formerly huissier, a French court officer) if the stakes justify it, with a musicologist's opinion if needed.
- Get advice from a specialized lawyer or a support organization; if you are a member of a collective management organization, find out about the services it offers.
- Try to settle it amicably, directly or through a lawyer, and use the platforms' reporting procedures if needed.
- Send a formal written notice demanding that the exploitation stop and/or compensation.
- File an infringement action before the competent court (tribunal judiciaire) if the disagreement continues. In principle, the civil action is time-barred five years from the day you knew, or should have known, the facts. In the US, a US work generally has to be registered with the US Copyright Office before you can sue for infringement (17 U.S.C. § 411).
Educational article based on French law, up to date as of October 2026. It does not replace personalized legal advice: for a specific situation, get help from a music law professional.